Sheffield Wednesday will always regret passing up on £3.6m transfer – he became a world-class striker

Sheffield Wednesday’s history is littered with both triumphs and missed opportunities.

Most Owls fans remember Eric Cantona training at Middlewood Road in early 1992 – a mercurial talent on trial who was deemed too risky to sign – but few recall that, just months later, Wednesday came even closer to landing a generational talent. In the summer of the same year, the club passed up the chance to sign Southampton’s 21-year-old Alan Shearer. The charge is £3.6 million. What is the cost of hesitation? Missing out on perhaps the best English striker of the modern era for an estimated £600,000.

Trevor Francis wanted Alan Shearer at Sheffield Wednesday – but the board refused

In his memoirs One in a Million, Trevor Francis, then Hillsborough’s player-manager, recounted how close Wednesday came to signing Shearer. Francis was convinced. “I have never been more certain about a player,” he said. “I told our chairman, Dave Richards, that if we spent £3 million on him, we’d double our money within a couple of years.”

Francis wasn’t alone in his assessment. Shearer had already broken into the England squad and was widely regarded as one of the country’s most promising forwards, but Wednesday’s board refused to pay more than £3 million, rejecting Southampton’s appraisal. Blackburn Rovers, buoyed by Jack Walker’s bold investment, stepped in and paid £3.6 million, a British transfer record at the time. The rest, as they say, was history.

Shearer’s impact on Blackburn was instant. Despite sustaining a significant knee injury in his debut season, he scored 16 goals in 21 appearances. When in peak condition, he was unstoppable. Thirty-one goals in 1993/94. Thirty-four in 1994/95 when Blackburn won the Premier League title. He won the FWA and PFA Player of the Year honours in consecutive years before joining Newcastle United for a then-world record £15 million in 1996. Shearer retired in 2006, having scored 260 Premier League goals, a record that currently holds. He captained England, won the Golden Boot at Euro 96, and established a household brand with an unparalleled legacy in English football history.

Wednesday’s near-miss is more devastating when considered in context. The club had recently returned to the top tier, finishing third in the First Division under Francis in 1991/92 and making both domestic cup finals in 1992/93. It was a moment of rebirth, but they fell short of major awards. Had Shearer arrived at Hillsborough, the story could have been quite different. Francis even recalls an attempt by his business partner, Nick Rogers, to personally fund the transaction.

“He wasn’t even a football man,” I heard Francis say, “but he asked, ‘Can’t we just buy him between us?'” It was not a possibility under the rules at the time. That alternative, which was famously considered years later in the Carlos Tevez case, was effectively ruled out. It’s easy to be smart after the fact, but Francis’ assurance, combined with Shearer’s future accomplishments, make this a case study in short-term caution trumps long-term vision. A striker who would go on to score 14 goals against the Owls in his career could have donned blue and white if the club had taken a prudent gamble. Three decades later, Wednesday supporters can only wonder what could have been. What is the cost of caution? £600,000 – and a place in football history rewritten forever.

Read more on sportupdates.co.uk