During the 2026 season so far, Otto Kemp hasn’t lived up to what the Phillies expected. A misguided front office placed all their hopes on a 26-year-old former undrafted free agent with less than a full year of big-league experience. Kemp showed in April he wasn’t the savior the Phillies needed, but given the team’s deep struggles against left-handed pitching, they’re giving him another shot in the hope he can fix some of those problems.
To be clear, Kemp isn’t the bad guy here. The California native turned himself into a major leaguer despite being overlooked by every team after college. In fact, he performed respectably, if unspectacularly, posting a .709 OPS over 218 MLB plate appearances in 2025. With decent speed and the ability to play multiple positions, he’s shown he can be a serviceable bench piece at the big-league level. Having Otto Kemp as the 26th man on the Phillies’ roster is perfectly fine.
Dave Dombrowski is the one hurting the Phillies, not Otto Kemp
Unfortunately, clueless president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski convinced himself Kemp was the reincarnation of Wes Chamberlain and would form a strong platoon in left field with Brandon Marsh playing the Jim Eisenreich role. That couldn’t have been more wrong, as Kemp stumbled to a tragic .100/.182/.100 slash line and played poor outfield defense over his first ten games this year before being sent down to Triple-A Lehigh Valley.
In his place, Dombrowski promoted rising prospect Felix Reyes, who had an excellent 1.000 OPS for the Ironpigs at the time. Reyes made headlines by homering off future Hall of Famer Chris Sale in his first MLB at-bat, but has managed only five hits in 37 plate appearances since then, also playing dreadful defense similar to Kemp’s.
Overall, the Phillies have been awful against left-handed pitching in 2026, with a collective .672 OPS over 555 plate appearances vs. southpaws. The lack of production from left field is a big reason for that hole, as the failures of both Kemp and Reyes have created even more uncertainty in a lineup full of left-handed hitters.
Dombrowski had plenty of chances over the winter to address an offense that has disappeared for long stretches over the past five seasons, yet he chose to do nothing. The failed pursuit of Bo Bichette was a nice try, but when that fell apart, Dombrowski pivoted to throwing too much money at an aging J.T. Realmuto and calling it quits. While fans are happy to have the beloved catcher back, that did nothing to strengthen a lineup that simply isn’t good enough.
Landing a star like Bichette would have been great, but Dombrowski had other options. He could have signed any number of veteran platoon outfielders like Rob Refsnyder, Miguel Andujar, Randal Grichuk, or old friend Austin Hays, all of whom took cheap one-year deals. Instead, he anointed the unproven Kemp as the heir apparent.
Despite everything, Kemp wasn’t given even the slightest leash. Ten games (admittedly terrible ones) were all it took for Dombrowski and his crew to give up on their harebrained plan and turn to Felix Reyes—the next sacrificial lamb.
Reyes has been unplayable for the Phillies, and the 25-year-old was clearly rushed to the majors to help patch a gaping hole created by the front office. Now that he’s shown he isn’t the answer in left field, Reyes has been sent back to Triple-A and Kemp has been recalled. Maybe this time things will click.
There are reasons to think Kemp will do better. His 2025 season was respectable enough, and the solid .792 minor-league OPS he’s put up since being demoted a few weeks ago seems far more reflective of his true ability than the brutal .282 mark he posted with the big club to start the year. Still, Kemp looks much more like a Quad-A depth player than a real difference-maker at this stage.
Dombrowski’s poorly thought-out roster construction has failed the Phillies repeatedly, and the Otto Kemp/Felix Reyes left-field circus is just the latest example of the game leaving the veteran executive behind. Phillies fans are all hoping Kemp will put it together this time, but if he doesn’t, they shouldn’t be angry at Kemp—they should be angry at the man who keeps setting the team up to fail: Dave Dombrowski.
Leave a Reply